Rooney: Foden cameo felt like ‘charity sub’

Foden’s Role Under Scrutiny After Final Cameo

Phil Foden’s late appearance in Manchester City’s EFL Cup final win has sparked debate, with Wayne Rooney describing it as a “charity substitution.”

What Happened?

• Foden came on in the 90th minute
• Replaced Rayan Cherki
• City already leading 2-0 vs Arsenal

Minimal impact opportunity in a major final

Rooney’s Strong Verdict

Rooney said:

“It felt like a charity sub… to get him on the pitch.”

He added:

• Strange Foden is not getting minutes
• Suggested something may have changed internally
• Highlighted how unusual it is for a player of his level

Foden’s Current Situation

• No goals in 20 matches
• Only 4 starts in last 13 games
• Unused in key matches (e.g. vs Real Madrid)

Meanwhile, players preferred ahead of him:

• Rayan Cherki
• Savinho
• Antoine Semenyo

Guardiola’s Selection Reality

Under Pep Guardiola:

• Form and tactical fit are everything
• Reputation doesn’t guarantee minutes
• Squad depth creates fierce competition

Even top players can quickly fall down the pecking order

Foden’s Response

Foden admitted:

“Football is not straightforward… there are ups and downs.”

• Staying focused on training
• Hoping to return sharper after international break

Professional attitude despite frustration

England & World Cup Concerns

• Included in England national football team squad
• But:
  • Role uncertain
  • Competition intense

World Cup place no longer guaranteed

What’s Really Going On?

Possible factors:

• Loss of form
• Tactical changes
• Confidence dip
• System not suiting his strengths

Or simply elite-level competition in City’s squad

Bottom Line

Foden’s situation is one of the biggest talking points at City:

From key player to fringe role

From starter to late cameo

But:

Talent isn’t in question — only timing and form