Is Bellingham Tuchel’s Star Asset or Tactical Dilemma?

Jude Bellingham: England’s Jewel or Tuchel’s Puzzle?

Jude Bellingham has quickly become one of England’s most gifted players, boasting 46 caps by age 22 and scoring at both the 2022 World Cup and Euro 2024. But under new head coach Thomas Tuchel, the Real Madrid star now finds himself at a crossroads.

Despite a flawless qualifying campaign for the 2026 World Cup, capped by a 2-0 win over Albania, Bellingham’s 84th-minute substitution and visible frustration have reignited debate over his standing in the squad. Tuchel’s comment that Bellingham’s behaviour would be “reviewed” only added fuel to the fire.

Reduced Role Under Tuchel

Since Tuchel’s arrival in January, Bellingham has seen his England minutes shrink—just 374 minutes across 10 games. While he started every match at Euro 2024, his recent appearances have been mostly off the bench, a stark contrast to his once-undisputed status.

Complicating matters is the fierce competition for the number 10 role: Phil Foden, Cole Palmer, Morgan Rogers, and Eberechi Eze are all in contention. Former England defender Stephen Warnock believes Rogers currently holds the shirt:

“It’s Morgan Rogers’ shirt at this moment. Jude will have to take it on the chin.”

A Star’s Frustration and a Manager’s Demands

Bellingham has scored three goals in 11 appearances for Alonso’s Real Madrid this season, missing six matches with a shoulder injury

Tuchel’s approach is direct and disciplined. He publicly called Bellingham’s on-field behaviour “repulsive” earlier this year—later apologising—but the incident left a lasting impression. The former PSG, Chelsea, and Bayern manager has a history of public player clashes, including with Kylian Mbappé and Callum Hudson-Odoi.

Still, Bellingham’s talent is beyond question. He helped Real Madrid win both La Liga and the Champions League, scoring 41 goals in 111 games since joining in 2023. In Madrid, he’s known for his professionalism and commitment.

“He is a leader at Real,” said Jesus Bengoechea of Madrid fan site La Galerna. “It surprises people that he’s not more acclaimed in England.”

Different Coaches, Different Chemistry

Observers note that Bellingham thrived under Ancelotti, a manager known for emotional intelligence, but has faced more structure under Xabi Alonso at Madrid and now Tuchel with England. The cold, tactical style may be a personality mismatch:

“It’s a matter of personalities that don’t gel,” added Bengoechea.

While some suggest he may be “disruptive,” others point out that Bellingham has consistently delivered in major tournaments. His ability to unlock defences and step up in big moments remains unmatched.

Conclusion: Tactical vs Personal

At heart, this seems to be less about discipline and more about tactical philosophy and managerial expectations. Tuchel’s England is built on flexibility, competition, and accountability—no matter your status.

Still, Bellingham is far from out of the picture. His performances remain sharp, and with a long build-up to the 2026 World Cup, his role may yet evolve into something central—if he can align with Tuchel’s demanding vision.

“If this is the worst problem England has,” said The England Pod’s David Walker, “then it’s a pretty good sign.”