James Trafford vs Ederson: Has the Time Come for a Changing of the Guard at Man City?
Having secured a return to his boyhood club, the new arrival from Burnley hasn't come to the Etihad to sit on the bench

James Trafford vs Ederson: Has the Time Come for a Changing of the Guard at Man City?

James Trafford vs Ederson: Guardiola’s Biggest Goalkeeping Decision Yet

Ederson Guardiola

Ederson Guardiola

If you’re Pep Guardiola, your biggest dilemma heading into the 2025-26 season isn’t who to play on the wings or whether to rotate Kevin De Bruyne. It’s in goal. And it’s one that could shape Manchester City’s immediate future—James Trafford vs Ederson, experience versus emergence.

Trafford, the academy-grown shot-stopper once let go by City, is back—and he’s not here to sit quietly on the bench. His recent return to the Etihad has reignited one of the most compelling goalkeeping debates in English football. On one hand, you have Ederson, the Brazilian playmaker in gloves, famous for his pinpoint passing and sweeping. On the other, you have Trafford, a penalty-saving phenom who’s just delivered a record-breaking Championship season. So… what now?

Cole Palmer Knew

Long before James Trafford was turning heads with clean sheets and penalty saves in England’s second tier, his former academy teammate Cole Palmer was calling it.

In the final of the U21 European Championship in 2023, with England clinging onto a 1-0 lead over Spain and a last-minute penalty awarded via VAR, Palmer sat on the bench and told Emile Smith-Rowe: “Bet you he saves this. Watch.” Trafford denied Abel Ruiz and then stopped the rebound too. England were champions. Palmer, grinning, reminded everyone: “Do you know how good this guy is?”

City clearly had some idea. Even as they allowed Trafford to join Burnley last summer, they inserted a buyback clause. Fast forward a year, and Newcastle’s interest triggered that clause—prompting City to bring Trafford home before he even truly unpacked in Lancashire.

Now he’s back. And suddenly, James Trafford vs Ederson isn’t just a training-ground talking point. It’s a genuine selection headache.

Ederson’s Reign: Under Scrutiny

Ederson’s numbers last season don’t lie. City conceded 44 league goals—the most they’ve let in since 2010. He was benched in November after a calamitous outing against Feyenoord in the Champions League. He returned to the side, only to produce more errors in a chaotic 3-3 draw against Juventus. All of this while Stefan Ortega, the usual second choice, also floundered—conceding 17 in 10 Premier League games and suffering a horror FA Cup Final against Crystal Palace.

Though Ederson’s passing remains elite, his shot-stopping has come under question. Once unshakeable, his command of the area and confidence now seem inconsistent. For a team like City—where one mistake can unravel 89 minutes of possession—the margin for error is razor-thin.

And so, Trafford enters the frame.

The Rise of James Trafford

James Trafford Burnley

James Trafford Burnley

Trafford’s 2024-25 season was nothing short of astonishing. After briefly losing his starting spot at Burnley, he reclaimed it and then some. He saved two penalties in a single game against Sunderland, went over 1000 minutes without conceding, and finished the campaign with 12 consecutive clean sheets—a Championship record.

Burnley conceded just 16 goals all season, another all-time low. Trafford played all but one match.

Of course, the natural rebuttal is: that’s the Championship, not the Premier League. True—but look deeper.

Trafford faced 103 shots on target last season and saved 85 of them. That’s an 85% save percentage. Ederson’s? Just 69.2%. When it comes to post-shot expected goals minus actual goals conceded—a metric used to evaluate how many goals a keeper actually prevents—Trafford’s value was 11.8. Ederson’s was five.

Even factoring in differences in opposition quality, that’s not a small gap. Trafford has shown that he’s more than capable of pulling off match-saving moments—and that’s something Ederson didn’t offer often enough last season.

A Question of Style

Still, this is Manchester City. It’s not just about shot-stopping. Pep wants a goalkeeper who can help build from the back, break the press, and dictate tempo. In this regard, Ederson is still peerless.

He made 1.90 defensive actions outside his area per 90 minutes, averaging a sweeping distance of 17.5 yards. Trafford averaged just 1.11 at 14.2 yards. That gap matters in Pep’s system, where every inch and second counts.

Passing-wise, Ederson is in his own universe. His short and medium pass completion rates hovered near perfection (98-100%), but it’s his long distribution that really stands out—seven Premier League assists in his career, and four just last season. Trafford’s long passing accuracy? Just 41.2%—a glaring drop-off.

That’s not to say Trafford can’t improve. He grew up in City’s academy, where the philosophy is drilled in early. Under Vincent Kompany and Scott Parker at Burnley, he saw both possession-heavy and more pragmatic styles. Reintegrating into City’s passing ethos might take a few months, but he has the fundamentals.

Contract Clock Ticking for Ederson

There’s another layer to this debate: Ederson is entering the final year of his contract. He turns 32 the day after City kick off their new season. With clubs like Napoli and Galatasaray reportedly circling (and Saudi interest never far off), this may be Ederson’s final chapter in Manchester.

If the two parties can’t agree on an extension, then City will need to prepare for life after him anyway. And that’s why Trafford is more than a backup. He’s a ready-made replacement in waiting, confident and eager.

This isn’t just about giving the young guy a few cup matches. Trafford is here to compete.

What Guardiola Might Do

Ederson Man City

Ederson Man City

So what’s the likely outcome in this James Trafford vs Ederson saga?

Expect Guardiola to start the season with Ederson—at least for now. His experience, distribution, and familiarity with the system still make him the safer pair of gloves for the early high-stakes fixtures.

But Trafford will be watching. Training hard. Pouncing on any slip-up.

And if Ederson has another rocky spell—or City decide not to renew—don’t be surprised if Trafford is the one stepping up before season’s end. He’s already proven he’s got the mentality. Now he just needs the minutes.

After all, as Cole Palmer said two summers ago, “Do you know how good this guy is?” Maybe it’s time we all found out.

Leave a Reply

There are no comments yet. Be the first to comment!