Man Utd Player Ratings vs Tottenham: Matthijs de Ligt That Is COLOSSAL!

Dutchman Spares Sleeping Manuel Ugarte & Shot-Shy Benjamin Sesko as Red Devils Rally in Crazy Ending

Football is nothing if not unpredictable. For Manchester United, that unpredictability often dances on the edge of heartbreak and hysteria, and their 2-2 draw against Tottenham Hotspur in North London was a perfect encapsulation of that fine line.

At 96 minutes, with Spurs already celebrating what they thought was a fifth straight win over United, Matthijs de Ligt rose like a warrior from the chaos and nodded home a priceless equaliser. The Dutchman’s last-gasp header not only salvaged a point but also spared Ruben Amorim’s side from another bruising defeat that might have dented their fragile confidence.

It wasn’t pretty, and it certainly wasn’t controlled — but it was classic United: messy, dramatic, and utterly captivating.

De Ligt the Hero as United Snatch a Point

United’s recent record against Thomas Frank’s Tottenham had been dismal — four straight losses, including that painful Europa League final defeat last season. So when Bryan Mbeumo’s header found the back of the net in the first half, it looked like Amorim’s new-look United might finally be turning a corner.

But football has a funny way of humbling teams that think the job’s done. Spurs roared back in the second half, taking advantage of United’s tired legs and tactical confusion after a string of questionable substitutions. Mathys Tel levelled the game with six minutes to go, before Richarlison’s flicked effort in stoppage time seemed to complete a stunning turnaround.

Then came the twist.

From a late corner, Bruno Fernandes — one of the few United players still demanding the ball and dictating play — sent in a teasing delivery. At the far post, De Ligt shrugged off his marker and nodded just over the line. Cue pandemonium.

A point rescued. Pride restored — at least temporarily.

Goalkeeper & Defence

Tottenham Hotspur v Manchester United – Premier League

Senne Lammens – 7/10

The young Belgian had an early wobble when a lazy passback from De Ligt rolled under his boot for a corner, but to his credit, he recovered well. His shot-stopping was superb — a smart block with his feet to deny Cristian Romero, followed by a fingertip save from Joao Palhinha’s half-volley. Commanded his area better as the game wore on, and couldn’t do much about either goal.

Matthijs de Ligt – 7/10

This was the De Ligt that United fans had been waiting for — strong, vocal, and decisive. Early on, he was occasionally caught out by Richarlison’s runs, but he quickly adjusted. And that goal — a thundering header under pressure in the 96th minute — was pure determination. A true captain’s performance without the armband.

Harry Maguire – 7/10

Rock solid until injury forced him off. Kept Kolo Muani quiet in the first half and looked composed alongside De Ligt. United’s defensive collapse coincided directly with his departure, which says plenty about how crucial he remains.

Luke Shaw – 6/10

Didn’t have much defending to do thanks to Patrick Dorgu’s excellent cover on his flank. Offered the occasional overlap but seemed reluctant to push too far forward. A steady but unspectacular outing.

Midfield

Tottenham Hotspur v Manchester United – Premier League

Noussair Mazraoui – 6/10

Operating in that hybrid role between right-back and midfield, Mazraoui looked composed in possession and disciplined defensively. Spurs’ inverted full-backs meant he wasn’t overloaded, but he didn’t add much offensively either. Replaced by Sesko as Amorim shifted shape.

Casemiro – 7/10

A vintage defensive performance — though one that underlined how much his legs have gone. Won crucial tackles and broke up play well but offered little creatively. Subbed for Manuel Ugarte, whose brief cameo proved catastrophic.

Bruno Fernandes – 7/10

If United had 11 players with his mentality, they might actually challenge for something. Always demanding the ball, always looking forward, and ultimately delivered the corner that rescued the draw. His leadership remains essential — even when the team around him falters.

Patrick Dorgu – 7/10

Perhaps his best game in a United shirt. Energetic, tactically aware, and brave in possession. Neutralised Spurs’ left-sided threats while offering balance going forward. Subbed off late as Amorim tried to lock things down.

Attack

FBL-ENG-PR-TOTTENHAM-MAN UTD

Amad Diallo – 7/10

Fresh from his heroics at Nottingham Forest, Amad continued to look like United’s liveliest attacking spark. His pinpoint cross for Mbeumo’s opener was pure quality. Worked tirelessly, even after being dropped into a deeper role once Sesko entered the pitch.

Bryan Mbeumo – 7/10

Scored against his old manager — and you could tell it meant something. Smart movement to peel off Pedro Porro for the opener. His work rate and tactical intelligence are already proving why United paid big money for him this summer. Another statement performance.

Matheus Cunha – 6/10

Deployed as a false nine, Cunha dropped deep to link play but often found himself isolated. Showed moments of flair and clever passing, but lacked end product. Subbed for Mount after fading in the second half.

Subs & Manager

FBL-ENG-PR-TOTTENHAM-MAN UTD

Benjamin Sesko – 3/10

Still adapting to the pace and physicality of English football — and it showed. Missed a golden opportunity to seal the win when one-on-one with Van de Ven, hesitated, and got clattered. Ended up injured, forcing United to finish with ten men. A miserable cameo.

Leny Yoro – 5/10

Came on for Maguire but didn’t replicate his authority. Looked hesitant and lost several aerial duels. Needs time to grow, but this was a reminder that Premier League football is unforgiving for youngsters.

Manuel Ugarte – 2/10

Ouch. This was one to forget. Beaten too easily by Odobert for Spurs’ equaliser, then lazily played Richarlison onside for their second. His introduction completely disrupted United’s shape.

Mason Mount – 5/10

Showed effort but had minimal impact. Failed to connect midfield and attack effectively. Still seems like a square peg in Amorim’s system.

Diogo Dalot – N/A

Introduced to shore things up defensively, but the collapse came from the other side. Unfair to pin any blame on him.

Ruben Amorim – 6/10

A tale of two halves for the Portuguese manager. His starting XI executed the plan well — compact, efficient, and clinical. But his substitutions were puzzling and nearly threw away all the good work. Taking off Casemiro for Ugarte and Dorgu for Dalot killed United’s rhythm. Still, credit where it’s due: the team fought to the last second, which says something about the mentality he’s trying to instil.

The Verdict: Chaos, Character, and Questions

If ever a match summed up the contradictions of Ruben Amorim’s Manchester United, this was it. Organized yet reckless. Dangerous yet fragile. Brilliant for spells, but far too often their own worst enemy.

They had the better of the first half, lost control in the second, and somehow still came away with something to show for it. In isolation, it’s a positive point away from home. In the bigger picture, though, it raises the same old questions about composure and game management.

De Ligt’s last-gasp header was more than just a goal — it was a lifeline. For the player, it was redemption after months of scrutiny. For the manager, it was a stay of execution after a series of results that could easily have gone the other way. And for the fans, it was a reminder that, no matter how chaotic this team remains, it still knows how to fight.

United are far from perfect. They’re still a work in progress under Amorim. But if there’s one thing this team proved at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium, it’s that they’ve rediscovered a bit of that old United spirit — the refusal to quit even when all seems lost.

And for that reason alone, they’ll take the point — even if, deep down, they know they probably should’ve taken all three.