Newcastle Slammed as ‘Idiots’ for Nick Woltemade Deal While Bayern Blast Stuttgart’s Transfer Stance
Newcastle United’s record-breaking summer signing of Nick Woltemade has caused a stir across Europe, with Bayern Munich legend Karl-Heinz Rummenigge taking aim at both Stuttgart and the Premier League club. The former Bayern chairman labelled Newcastle “idiots” for splashing out nearly £74 million on the 22-year-old striker, sarcastically congratulating Stuttgart for cashing in on a player they had fought to keep all summer.
The comments have sparked a heated debate over rising transfer fees, Financial Fair Play (FFP), and the growing financial gap between the Bundesliga and the Premier League.
Bayern’s Failed Pursuit of Nick Woltemade
For Bayern Munich, the chase for Nick Woltemade was one of the main talking points of the summer. After his breakout campaign with Stuttgart, where he became one of the most promising young forwards in the Bundesliga, Bayern made the striker a priority target.
The German champions launched several bids, with their final offer reportedly reaching €60 million (£52m/$70m). Stuttgart, however, stood firm, insisting they would only sell for €75m (£65m/$87m) or more. With Bayern unwilling to go that high, it appeared that Woltemade would remain at the club for another season.
Then came Newcastle United. Backed by their Saudi Arabian owners, the Magpies swooped in with a stunning €85m (£74m/$99m) package that included add-ons and convinced Stuttgart to part ways with their star forward. The move broke Newcastle’s transfer record and sent shockwaves through the Bundesliga, leaving Bayern frustrated and empty-handed.
Rummenigge Mocks Newcastle for Overpaying
Karl-Heinz Rummenigge didn’t hold back when asked for his thoughts on the deal. Speaking to German broadcaster Blickpunkt Sport, the Bayern legend was scathing about the price Newcastle were willing to pay.
“I can only congratulate Stuttgart for finding, so to speak, an idiot who would pay that much money,” he said with a wry smile. “Because we certainly wouldn’t have done that. We reached a scale that I no longer find acceptable, and we decided not to meet their demands.”
His comments reflect Bayern’s long-standing approach to transfers, preferring to stay financially disciplined rather than engage in bidding wars. However, they also underline a growing frustration among Bundesliga executives at being priced out of the market by Premier League clubs.
Premier League vs Bundesliga: The Growing Gap
Rummenigge’s criticism wasn’t just directed at Newcastle — he used the opportunity to highlight the growing disparity between English clubs and their European counterparts. The Premier League’s lucrative broadcasting deals and wealthy ownership groups have created a market where even mid-table sides can outspend most of Europe’s giants.
“The Premier League has moved far ahead financially,” Rummenigge warned. “It’s difficult for German clubs to compete when English clubs can offer higher wages, bigger transfer fees, and still operate within their own version of FFP.”
He also called out players and agents for pushing up transfer fees and wages, warning that such spending is unsustainable. “The players and their agents must also be careful not to trap themselves,” he said. “The money has to come from somewhere, and that means either expanding competitions or creating new ones. That can’t be the future of football.”
Losing Florian Wirtz to Liverpool Adds to Bayern’s Frustration
The Nick Woltemade saga wasn’t Bayern’s only transfer setback. The club also saw a €100m (£87m/$117m) bid for Florian Wirtz turned down by Bayer Leverkusen earlier in the summer, only for Liverpool to step in and land the German playmaker for €125m (£108m/$146m) — a new British record.
For Rummenigge, this was another sign of the widening gap between the Bundesliga and England. “We can no longer compete with the top Premier League clubs for players at this level,” he admitted. “Either we find a way to increase our own financial power, or we risk losing the best German talents to England year after year.”
Financial Fair Play Concerns and 50+1 Debate
Rummenigge also used the opportunity to renew his call for stricter FFP enforcement and even hinted that Bayern may have to reconsider Germany’s 50+1 ownership rule — which limits private investors’ control over clubs — to remain competitive.
“Currently, clubs are allowed to spend 70 percent of their income on salaries and transfers,” he explained. “We need to bring that down to 60, ideally even 55 percent, because anything above 55 means you are losing money. Football cannot be the only industry in the world that only loses money.”
The comments are likely to fuel further debate within German football about whether the 50+1 model, which prioritizes supporter ownership, is still sustainable in an era where state-backed clubs like Newcastle, Manchester City, and Paris Saint-Germain dominate the market.
Bayern’s Concerns for the Next Transfer Window
Looking ahead, Rummenigge fears that Bayern’s struggles could be repeated in the next transfer window if action isn’t taken soon. He called for a serious conversation between Bundesliga clubs, the DFL (German Football League), and UEFA about how to level the playing field.
“We should sit down at a table and discuss what we can do together,” he said. “It’s not like someone immediately runs to the European Court of Justice after the meeting and sues. We need to protect German football before it becomes impossible to keep our best players.”
Newcastle Betting Big on Woltemade
As for Newcastle, they will hope that their investment in Nick Woltemade proves worthwhile. The young striker arrives with plenty of potential and will be tasked with leading the line as Eddie Howe looks to build a side capable of competing both in the Premier League and in Europe.
Whether he justifies the £74m price tag remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: the deal has turned heads across Europe and reignited the debate about football’s financial future.
There are no comments yet. Be the first to comment!